I listen intently as Solange describes their most recent argument. It happened as it often did for them, in the car as they were driving to meet up with her parents and running late. She felt anxious about how her husband Blake was driving; he felt annoyed by her commentary on how he was driving. It was another ordinary moment for them that turned into another rapid escalation, until she was screaming at him to pull over and just let her out, while he said nothing and drove faster.
In session with me a few days later, each made their case about why the other person was wrong during that car ride. They were each convinced that if they could just share their point-of-view, I would side with them and the fight would thus be resolved.
But I had no interest in helping them relitigate this argument. Instead, I was curious about why they had each gotten so triggered in the first place.
In my 30 years of counseling married couples, I see how often old narratives and imprints, buried beneath the surface, can rise up in these ordinary arguments and hijack the present moment. Why are you so angry that your spouse is driving 5 miles over the speed limit? Why are you so upset that your spouse has asked you to slow down? Is it really about that, or is it something else?
Three questions to ask yourself when small moments become big fights
When you find yourself reacting at a level that seems disproportionate to the issue at hand, you might want to consider what else is going on. Of course on one level your upset is connected to what is currently happening. But if you find yourself questioning your whole marriage or blaming your partner in ways you did not at the beginning of your relationship, then maybe something else is going on.
Here are three exercises to help you sort this out.
1. What is the unmet need underneath your complaint?
Often the thing we complain about is pointing the way to what we really yearn for from our partner. Whether you vociferously express your complaint or keep it to yourself and shrug it off, it’s often a clue to what is missing for you in the relationship. Imagine, as an example, that you find yourself frequently annoyed by your spouse leaving their stuff on the kitchen counter, then ask yourself what you wish was happening instead.
Do you long for an uncluttered space? Does the sight of clutter stress you out?
Do you want him to accommodate a plan you have set up for keeping the house organized?
Do you want to have less chores on your plate and more on hers?
Do you want to go out and have fun together, because maybe deep down you don’t care about the piles of stuff, you just notice that it gets more irritating when you start spending less quality time together?
Perhaps the conversation will go better if you say what it is you really need.
2. How else might you respond when you get frustrated with your spouse?
Think back to when you were in elementary school, sometime between the ages of 5-12 years old. Think about something you can remember getting really frustrated about. Maybe it was that your mom was always late to pick you up, or that your dad always blamed you for the fights you got into with your brother.
Now think about what you did in response to this frustration. If I was a fly on the wall of your childhood home, what would I have seen you do? Argue with your parents? Not say anything? Sulk? Leave the house to go be with your friends?
We all experienced frustration when we were children. And we all found ways to cope with those moments, for better or worse. At some point we became very attached to this coping style as we grew up, until it became so automatic we weren’t even aware of doing it.
Fast forward to your married life. Here you are, a 30 or 40-something adult, and still using the coping mechanisms you first learned as an 8-year-old. Your spouse isn’t driving the way you want them too? You have a temper tantrum the way you did with your mom when she insisted you clean your room. Your spouse comments on your driving? You give her the silent treatment the way you did to your dad when he criticized your school performance.
Perhaps it’s time to try something else.
3. What are you insisting upon right now that may no longer be serving you?
Think about that time when you first really felt like you were on your own in the world. Maybe it was in your teens, or early 20s. Remember that moment when you realized, I am really on my own right now.
Now remember the next few years after that moment. Just cast your mind gently over those years and notice what character strengths you developed in the wake of that moment. What positive personality traits became stronger in you? What did you figure out about yourself when you first realized you were on your own?
For many people, the strengths you discovered in yourself back then became your superpower, maybe even your core sense of self. Most of us get very attached to this part of ourselves, especially since it is often what runs our adult lives so effectively. We can end up using this part even when it isn’t helpful at all, so dependent were we on it for figuring life out way back when.
When Solange stopped blaming Blake for the argument they had in the car, she was able to recognize how much she struggled when she felt a loss of control. She connected these moments with Blake to how she felt when she first went off to college, the first in her family to do so, and how she found in herself the capacity to succeed because she was willing to work so hard at her studies. Twenty years later, she finds it uncomfortable to let go of using the very thing that helped her get to where she is in her life.
When Blake stopped being defensive towards Solange, he came to understand how much his silent resistance to her came from that old place inside him: the one that shut down in the face of parental criticism and control, that kept his core self buried deep inside so that no one else could hurt him. Twenty years later, he sometimes gets stuck behind the wall that saved him back then.
Now you get to have a new conversation, one that might actually help you move on from the arguments you and your partner have been having for years. Next time you notice yourself mired in one of these circular arguments, see if you can instead get curious about what else might be going on.
Author Bio
Melinda Yachnin, LCPC, is a Licensed Clinical Professional Counselor in La Grange and Chicago IL. She specializes in couples counseling for people in long-term relationships and has been counseling couples for almost 30 years in the Chicago area. She uses Gottman Method, Imago Therapy, EFT and RLT in her work with couples so that couples can access the practical skills in everyday life and the deeper currents that can transform their relationships. She has been married for 25 years and raised three children with her husband, a perspective that has enhanced her commitment to helping couples navigate the many stages of a life together.